All Chapters

Your Next Chapter at Home · Chapter 1

October 10, 2026

Stay or Move? You Don't Have to Decide Today

Stay or MoveLongtime Homeowners

If you’ve been in your house a long time, you’re in good company here.

Across Madison, about one in four homeowners moved in before 2000. That’s according to the latest Census figures. In some of our most established neighborhoods, it’s closer to one in two. Glen Oak Hills, Regent, Waunona, Hawthorne and the Woodland Hills area on the far west side all sit around 45 to 47 percent. Monona’s Dellwood area tops the list at nearly half. Out my way, Cross Plains is about 37 percent.

In these neighborhoods, 35–48% of homeowners have stayed 20+ years, vs. 25% citywide Share of owner-occupied homes whose owner moved in before 2000
  • Monona (Dellwood area) 48%
  • Woodland Hills area (far west) 47%
  • Waunona 47%
  • Regent 47%
  • Glen Oak Hills 47%
  • Hawthorne 45%
  • Prairie Hills (southwest) 45%
  • Dudgeon-Monroe 42%
  • Hill Farms 42%
  • Lake Edge 42%
  • Brentwood Village (north side) 39%
  • Bay Creek 39%
  • Cross Plains (ZIP 53528) 37%
  • Woodside Heights, Middleton 35%

City of Madison: 25%

Source: U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey 2020–2024 5-year estimates, table B25038 (via Census Reporter). Census tracts labeled by nearest neighborhood.

I love that. It says something about these neighborhoods: people put down roots, raised families, coached Little League, planted the maples that now shade the street, and stayed.

It also means a lot of us are quietly asking the same question. Is this still the right house for the next 10 or 20 years?

For many people, the decision to stay or move isn’t made overnight. It’s often something you’ve turned over for months, or even years. Your home holds memories, routines and a real sense of comfort. So the question can stir up a mix of feelings: uncertainty, excitement, relief, and sometimes a little anxiety.

Here’s the good news. You don’t have to decide today. This post isn’t about talking you into anything. It’s about helping you think it through, so that when the time is right, you can move forward (or stay put) with confidence.

Start with the big question

Is it time to stay, or time to move?

There’s no right answer. The best choice is the one that supports your lifestyle, your finances, your health and your peace of mind. Some people will read this and realize they’re exactly where they want to be. Others will realize they’ve been tolerating more than they’d like to admit. Either way, it helps to put it on paper.

What do you love about your home?

Before you weigh any options, name what you’d hate to lose. For a lot of longtime owners, it’s things like:

  • Your community: the neighbors who wave, the friends down the block, your church or your coffee spot
  • Your garden, or the lake, or the bike path you’ve walked a thousand times
  • Familiar surroundings, and knowing exactly where everything is
  • Your privacy
  • Being close to friends and family

Write these down. Knowing what matters most will guide every decision after this one. And if you do move someday, this list is what you’ll look for in your next place.

What are your pain points?

Now be honest about the challenges. Do any of these sound familiar?

  • The stairs are getting harder, or the laundry is in the basement
  • There’s more house to clean and maintain than you need or want
  • Utility and repair bills keep creeping up (the roof, the furnace, the driveway)
  • Snow shoveling and yard work feel like a part-time job
  • You’re feeling more isolated than you used to
  • You worry about what happens if your mobility changes

Here’s something I’ve noticed over the years: the things we tolerate today often become the reasons we choose to move tomorrow. It’s worth noticing them now, while you still have plenty of choices.

Who is on your support team?

Big decisions are easier when you don’t make them alone. Think about who belongs in your circle:

  • Family members
  • Trusted friends
  • A financial advisor
  • An estate planning attorney
  • A Seniors Real Estate Specialist® (SRES®), an agent trained to help older homeowners weigh these exact decisions

You don’t need all of them at once. But a conversation or two can turn a vague worry into a clear picture.

Think about timing

Sometimes timing makes all the difference. A few questions to ask yourself:

  • Is there a benefit to planning ahead, rather than waiting for circumstances to force a decision?
  • Would making a move now give you more choices and more control?
  • What would need to happen for you to feel ready?

That second question matters more than people expect. When a move is planned, you choose the house, the neighborhood and the timeline. When it’s rushed by a fall, a health change or a long winter, those choices often get made for you, or fall to your kids.

Planning doesn’t mean committing

If you take one thing from this post, let it be this: planning doesn’t mean committing. It simply means understanding your options.

You might go through these questions and decide you’re staying right where you are, maybe with a few changes that make the house work better as you age. That’s a great outcome. Or you might realize you’re more ready than you thought. That’s a great outcome too.

Over the next few posts in this series, I’ll walk through both paths: what it takes to age in place well, what downsizing (or “rightsizing”) can look like, and the housing options here in Dane County that many people don’t know exist.

And if you’d ever like to talk it through over a cup of coffee, no pressure and no timeline, I’m always happy to be a sounding board.

Sources and more information